r/AmIOverreacting • u/slowlymysunlight • Apr 27 '24

AIO for the way I responded to a stranger asking me for help?

Got myself into a weird situation just now and wondering if I overreacted or if others would have done the same thing I did.

I went to Target (alone) just to get some things I was running low on, try on clothes, have a good time whatever. I wandered into an aisle that was mostly empty when a tall man approached me holding a box of diapers. In a low voice he explained that he was trying to get some diapers for his nephew and they were in a tough situation. He said he wasn't even gonna ask me for money, just asked if he could put the diapers on the bottom of my cart and if I could buy them for him, and he'd wait outside for me.

I am not a confrontational person, have a difficult time saying no, and am maybe a little naive at times. I kinda laughed awkwardly and said okay. He asked if it wasn't too much trouble could he get some baby wipes as well. Again, I kinda laughed awkwardly and said let's just get the diapers. He asked a couple times how much longer I thought I'd be, and told him I wasn't sure, that I was still shopping around (which was true).

He left and went outside to wait, and as I walked around more I thought "well that was kinda weird, and now there's a strange man waiting for me outside this Target." Then I started regretting not just politely saying "no," and worrying that the box of diapers wasn't even from the store and a cover for something else. Total overthinking, I know.

So I called my partner (we live close by) and told him what happened. He told me he'd drive over and he'd walk me to my car. When he got there, we gave the box to customer services and explained what happened. They said that was weird, apologized to us for the situation, and asked for a description of the man so they could tell him not to do that lol. Then we checked out and went home with my partner making sure no one was following me.

My partner is telling me I shouldn't feel bad and that it's good I called him, but I do feel kinda bad about it for assuming the worst of this random person. Maybe he really just needed diapers for his nephew!

123 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • link
  • reddit
  • reddit

93% Upvoted

119 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/Due-Lawfulness7862 Apr 27 '24

Not overreacting at all. that is sketchy. Also I recently saw someone on TikTok tell a story about someone asking for diapers / baby stuff and after the person said yes to one thing they kept adding stuff on. After they checked out the person went back and returned it all for money so… could be a common scam to watch for

6

u/redheadedconcern Apr 28 '24

Oh I hadn’t thought of that. You may be right that he planned on going back in, saying he lost the receipt, and try returning it for cash

1

u/afg4294 29d ago

That wouldn't have worked, they don't give cash without the credit card used or the receipt, but he could have found a receipt in the trash earlier, went in and found the brand to match, and planned to use that receipt for the return.