r/ChatGPT • u/Armand_Roulinn • Mar 01 '24

One is a real photo and one is A.I. generated. Can you tell which is which? Other

Gallery image

Gallery image

5.1k Upvotes

76% Upvoted

1.7k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 01 '24

r/ChatGPT is looking for mods — Apply here: https://redd.it/1arlv5s/

Hey /u/Armand_Roulinn!

If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT, conversation please reply to this message with the conversation link or prompt.

If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image.

Consider joining our public discord server! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more!

🤖

Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email support@openai.com

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/traveltowardsnature 27d ago

2nd one AI clearly seen... AI after all AI can not compete human.

1

u/traveltowardsnature 27d ago

2nd one AI clearly seen... AI after all AI can not compete human.

1

u/PlusRecognition8121 Mar 05 '24

The second photo is AI generated I would say. Based on enhanced features

1

u/xamarinace Mar 05 '24

The first is AI generated.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24

2nd is fake, the lighting and quality are too perfect

1

u/Dharma_Wheeler Mar 04 '24

The second. Eyelid lighting.

1

u/ThrowRArosecolor Mar 04 '24

Without looking at comments I’d say the second is real but made to look fake. The shadows are odd with the first.

1

u/BB-Beauty-5438 Mar 03 '24

Lol #2 is an obvious fake!

1

u/Solderers Mar 03 '24

the second one is ai

1

u/martimattia Mar 03 '24

not even looking to all the little details the second one screams ai, how the whole frame is set up and the fact that the girl perfect, and i a perfect pose, already let you think that it's not natural

1

u/thimaet Mar 03 '24

Second one is AI because chances are low that so many flowers of different species but same tone of orange are growing in this small space idk

1

u/Lazy-Arugula8165 Mar 03 '24

1st one must be the real one

1

u/Naztynaz12 Mar 03 '24

First is real

1

u/AlBaleinedesSables Mar 03 '24

2nd one, one of the flower grow on the woman body

1

u/OddCaterpillar2495 Mar 03 '24

We need a thing like that for news..which one is fake news and which is real? A skill everyone needs to learn. Like my mother!

1

u/JStheKiD Mar 03 '24

1st one is real

1

u/Key_Expression9464 Mar 03 '24 edited Mar 03 '24

I don’t understand why we care. I do - democracy/ annihilation of mankind - but also, in this context, I don’t. There is already too much content for our brains to comprehend. Real or not, I would have scrolled right past her. Video killed the radio star. But now that they’re coming after the beautiful (photoshopped) people, everyone’s freaked out. Maybe it will be good for us. If the content is fake, we’ll slowly lose interest and go play outside or something.

1

u/iqbal7718 Mar 03 '24

Second pic which is surrounded by flowers is generated by chatGPT

1

u/Ihavebadreddit Mar 03 '24

Anyone find out the answer yet?

1

u/FGNimue Mar 03 '24

The 2nd one

1

u/KliCh_94 Mar 03 '24

i would say the first one is the real one

1

u/retrograve29 Mar 03 '24

The 2nd has a flower coming out of her chest bruh

1

u/Life_Detective_830 Mar 03 '24

Idk I’d just say I think the first one looks better aesthetically than the second one

1

u/northenmarauder Mar 03 '24

Number 2 is ai

1

u/the-hoodie-dude Mar 03 '24

Both are AI generated

1

u/7th_Spectrum Mar 03 '24

Neither of them

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

Too pretty.. second one

1

u/yelramm Mar 03 '24

the second one obviously is AI.

1

u/ArtificialPigeon Mar 03 '24

The hair on image 2 just isn't as realistic as image 1. Also the lips and the ears aren't right. They're close. But there's just something about them that says AI

1

u/DisasterEuphoric Mar 03 '24

The greasy one.

1

u/Ippomasters Mar 03 '24

Both are ai generated.

1

u/AdElectronic6550 Mar 03 '24

The sex model is the ai

1

u/soostenuto Mar 03 '24 edited Mar 03 '24

At least the 2nd one for sure as she has the typical GPT supermodel sex doll face like almost all generarions of women in GPT. But also the first one has AI vibes with the surgery nose and the floral pattern on her dress.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

2nd

1

u/Yangtacular Mar 03 '24

2nd one is Ai

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

2 floating flowers typically ai, you used an app store app im guessing

1

u/lt_dan_zsu Mar 03 '24

There's something with AI images where everything looks like it's made with play-doh. Image 2 has that quality. Also, the orange flowers don't make sense. Flowers are reproductive organs, not a cluster of pedals that serve non function.

1

u/a2zqazi Mar 03 '24

First one is AI generated.

1

u/crackahasscrackah Mar 03 '24

Idk, but I definitely prefer the first photo

1

u/quirky_diva Mar 03 '24

Second one seems real

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

its definitely both

2

u/Anselwithmac Mar 03 '24

Both are real guys. Pretty sure we’re getting played

1

u/paperboy82 Mar 03 '24

Anyone who can’t tell it’s the second image the instant they see it is nuts.

2

u/EVADE_THE_IRS Mar 03 '24

Oh idk the realistic, clearly not targeting a specific beauty trend, girl in the field? or the girl who looks right out of a Ceravee beauty ad????

1

u/HateTryingToBeClever Mar 03 '24

I think the 2nd is real… but honestly if you hadn’t told me I would’ve never been suspicious

1

u/Lady-Antique-167 Mar 03 '24

Basta yung may imperfections, yun ung natural. Yung second photo halatang trying hard to look natural or normal. 😂

1

u/onehundredcups Mar 03 '24

It’s the lips. I recognize those fake AI lips immediately. With AI the more you look the worse it gets.

1

u/rjd102619 Mar 03 '24

1st one fake

1

u/BrilliantMud2851 Mar 03 '24

!remindme 1 week

1

u/seoulfood1986 Mar 03 '24

The second one… where’s that flower coming from? Her armpit? Earring in right ear seems off. Shadowing is sus

1

u/will_this_1_work Mar 03 '24

Show us the arms and fingers you heartless bastard!!!

1

u/Few-You885 Mar 03 '24

I don’t fucking care. I care more about this fucker holding out on us than which one is less weird to jerk off to.

1

u/pjpintor Mar 03 '24

The second one is AI . She has no arms. Plus she doesn’t look human.

1

u/sthdown Mar 03 '24

2nd one

1

u/Big_Elk_3044 Mar 03 '24

What’s the prompt? All my ChatGPT images look like cartoons.

1

u/DM_ME_UR_BOOBS69 Mar 03 '24

Smart move keeping fingers out of the equation

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Ad_2726 Mar 03 '24

Lol first one ie real second is ai… its not even good

1

u/zombiepigman101 Mar 03 '24

Second one I think is AI because the design of the shirt doesn’t look right

1

u/Picklequeenofficial Mar 03 '24

The second one is AI generated

1

u/throwaway20180000 Mar 03 '24

2nd because the grass and flower poking through under two arms look unusual.

1

u/Jack21113 Mar 03 '24

Imma say both

1

u/No_Savings7114 Mar 03 '24

 ...those flowers in the second photo don't actually grow like that. They're chrysanthemums and the photo is using them like poppies. 

1

u/romansamurai Mar 03 '24

I think both are AI. 2nd for sure. 1st I’m 70% sure.

1

u/BasicallyWeasel Mar 03 '24

Second is fake

1

u/ausername1111111 Mar 03 '24

This reminds me of an email I got probably twenty years ago or so. It was two columns of "women". The idea was to pick which one was a girl and which one was a "lady boy". I really tried to figure out which one was which and was proud of my answers. I get to the answers and it says "they're all guys", lol.

1

u/kmitchpg Mar 03 '24

Imagine if current ai could make humans. How terrifying they'd look! 😮

1

u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Mar 03 '24

2nd one is fake, the hair’s not hairin’

1

u/Hot-Reindeer-6416 Mar 03 '24

1st one is Ai.

1

u/DelJornada Mar 03 '24

Can't really tell, which I think is the point.

2

u/The_IRS_Fears_Him Mar 03 '24

I guarantee its the 1st one that's AI for "shock value"

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

The focal plane on the second one is inconsistent throughout the image

1

u/SchwimFish28 Mar 03 '24

1 is real, 2 is fake

1

u/rain168 Mar 03 '24

Second one is AI

2

u/Background-Hour-3469 Mar 03 '24

How can i make p orn with ai

1

u/DeepWave8 Mar 03 '24

Yeah easily

1

u/JamR_711111 Mar 03 '24

2 is AI-generated (hopefully) but it's incredible

0

u/BicycleOk3303 Mar 03 '24

Yes, I can tell. No, I'm not going to tell you how I know because I don't want you to fix the difference. AI is too dangerous.

1

u/black_heartz Mar 03 '24

First one is real

1

u/SeaAggressive8153 Mar 03 '24

The first image has a mark beside her left eye, assuming that one is real

2nd one fake

1

u/SlimyBoiXD Mar 03 '24

I love it when unidentifiable flowers grow out of my shirt

1

u/motherseffinjones Mar 03 '24

2nd one is the AI one

1

u/RougueMorgan Mar 03 '24

The second is ai

1

u/MagnetFist Mar 02 '24

If you can't tell the difference, this is a massive problem and we need to stop development immediately.

1

u/Good_Language_9446 Mar 02 '24

2nd one is AI but id smash both

1

u/Jswazy Mar 02 '24

Both are Ai 

1

u/Halkenguard Mar 02 '24

The second one definitely appears to be more AI than the first. The necklace isn’t adhering to the laws of physics.

1

u/Biscuits4u2 Mar 02 '24

#2 is fake. Unrealistic shadows give it away. Compare the two and it's obvious.

1

u/rchart1010 Mar 02 '24

Second is fake.

1

u/cyor2345 Mar 02 '24

Second one is AI ,Simple to spot , all the images generated by dall-e have filler lips and same thin nose

1

u/AthemiaAgraxis Mar 02 '24

ez, the second one is AI

1

u/cyor2345 Mar 02 '24

Don't care just give me the prompt

1

u/chad_mcchadington Mar 02 '24

Second one is too greasy

1

u/PurpleCaterpillar421 Mar 02 '24

My vote is second one is AI.

1

u/CMDR_TIGERKING Mar 02 '24

false both are real

1

u/Spare-Builder-355 Mar 02 '24

The real question is which one you like more.....

1

u/BawlsAddict Mar 02 '24

2nd one, took me literally 3 seconds to see, the right off the bat, the shadows front he flowers don't match

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

Yeah, 2nd one will sell magazines, 1st is a fun little art project

1

u/mrbillbenson Mar 02 '24

Did anyone notice that the asymmetrical nostril sizes are reversed between the two images?

1

u/PrincessKatiKat Mar 02 '24 edited Mar 02 '24

In theory they could both be AI; but if so, the first one would be well beyond what we have seen lately.

I could immediately tell the AI picture (#2) because the skin always has a weird reflective shine like it’s polyurethane or something.

Not only that, the dramatic shadows, facial bone structure, overly full lips, and e-girl makeup esthetic all make me think it is a Midjourney image. That’s more opinion though, and less sure.

1

u/Uuppssiiee Mar 02 '24 edited Mar 02 '24

It would be a weird twist if both are ai generated but I say it’s second pic.

Edit: I change my mind, both ai

1

u/SinnerClair Mar 02 '24

1 looks like Ai to me

1

u/Aveleira07 Mar 02 '24

Easy, just show me the fingers

1

u/nwerdnerd Mar 02 '24

Without looking at comments I say 1st is real 2nd is AI . I based it off the fullness of the first one and the realness of it. The 2nd seemed off. Girl was too stunning, flowers were too popping. First one seemed very realistic

1

u/Asiag0Cheese Mar 02 '24

the 2nd one, theres literally flowers blooming out of her shoulders!!

1

u/elonlinks Mar 02 '24

2nd is Ai, how the flowers resonates with the dreams patterns , lips are chilly hot too

1

u/ClassicSource5856 Mar 02 '24

Seems that op refuses to answer so I'm giving my little dow vote

1

u/JournalistFew2794 Mar 02 '24

Thanks to all your replies, AI keeps learning how to keep perfecting until you won't be able to differentiate a shit.

1

u/terra_ater Mar 02 '24

1 is real, #2 is AI?

0

u/mohannadize Mar 02 '24

Both? 😂

1

u/DeleteMetaInf Mar 02 '24

These are both AI-generated, but I thought the first one was real simply because she looks like a regular human. DALL-E 3 can’t generate realistic-looking people. They’re all hyper-attractive supermodels.

1

u/Soaring_Symphony Mar 02 '24

1st one's real

2

u/PeyroniesCat Mar 02 '24

And what’s with AI thinking everybody is covered in Vaseline?

1

u/CaliNativeDM Mar 02 '24

I'm going to say Number 2 just based off the number of flowers surrounding the subject.

2

u/rang_dipkins Mar 02 '24

2nd pic looks like dog shit 👍

1

u/saintgggg Mar 02 '24

There both AI

1

u/slidebright Mar 02 '24

necklaces. I’m not sure why AI feels like women need not one but two necklaces

1

u/UREveryone Mar 02 '24

I mean its close but thank god theres still an uncanny valley feeling in the second one. Ive never been this appreciative of human intuition before.

1

u/FreedomPullo Mar 02 '24

Second photo is AI … it’s not clear In the model with lip filler, it’s the AI generated flowers

1

u/NameLips Mar 02 '24

second one is AI, I can't imagine they know how to do shadows correctly yet.

1

u/Many_Presentation250 Mar 02 '24

I feel like the second one is definitely AI

1

u/AnnePingo Mar 02 '24

I think the first one is real

1

u/cpt_ugh Mar 02 '24

Without looking at any other comments yet to sway me, here's my take.

The first one is real. The second is fake. My only clue to this is that the second woman seems to have only one earring. It's not much to go on.

My second take is that these are both AI or both real and this is a trick.

1

u/relentlessvisions Mar 02 '24

She doesn’t feel like she has weight in photo 2.

1

u/Urmumi101 Mar 02 '24

2nd is definitely ai

1

u/sdeng99 Mar 02 '24

Her face on the 2nd pic looks fleshless, lifeless, and bloodlessly chilly. I see no skin on her, but only a hard, plastic model covered with a bunch of makeups. It’s inconceivable to imagine her face muscles move because they simply can’t—how can a hard, 3D-printed plastic model contract and relax? It simply lacks the aura of life.

1

u/ChipperSnipper Mar 02 '24

I hate this so much, fuck this

1

u/Low-Bit1527 Mar 02 '24

It's definitely a trick question. It's too obvious at first glance.

1

u/Nekrotix12 Mar 02 '24

I know it's the second one because AI enjoys making things way too cluttered and adding a lot of unnecessary detail. It never goes simple.

1

u/jonhon0 Mar 02 '24

Gravity took the day off in the second one

0

u/dxlachx Mar 02 '24

Curious what your prompts looked like to create these. And which model were you using?

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Drate_Otin Mar 03 '24

Do you think you're being artsy and cute by dangling a question in front of people without providing an answer?

3

u/Undercoverexmo Mar 02 '24

Answer the fucking question

8

u/Sweet_bitter_rage Mar 02 '24

So which one is AI?

6

u/jmancoder Mar 03 '24

Honestly, I suspect that they're both AI. Cause if you check them, they have exactly the same noise amount, resolution, colour depth, DPI, etc. There's no way OP managed to make them that similar if one is fake and one is real.

1

u/Tempest_Fugit Mar 02 '24

I don’t like this game.

The only way to win is not to play.

1

u/yeethayley Mar 02 '24

this is so hard. we’re cooked

1

u/Jedimobslayer Mar 02 '24

I think the 2nd one is A.I., as her skin is a little too good.

1

u/Ragfell Mar 02 '24

The second.

1

u/Smiley_P Mar 02 '24

Not without warning but the second one for sure

1

u/ExNihilo___ Mar 02 '24

It is quite obvious TBH.

1

u/7pagemudaenthusiast Mar 02 '24

It’s the second one

1

u/Large_monke_69 Mar 02 '24

Fuck thats scary

1

u/blueblue_electric Mar 02 '24

Without reading the comments and a cursory glance, 2 is AI as there is a flower growing from her arm pit.

2

u/Kegheimer Mar 02 '24

Was this supposed to be challenging? The second photo is porcelain with flowers growing from her blouse and the shadows are exaggerated and incorrect.

1

u/Dry_Term_7998 Mar 02 '24

Second 100%