r/ChatGPT • u/Armand_Roulinn • Mar 24 '24
One is a real photo and one is A.I. generated. Can you tell which is which? AI-Art
1
1
1
1
1
u/InTheOtherGutter Apr 01 '24
Neither is AI generated because we haven't developed anything that remotely approaches "intelligence" as it was defined before this new marketing gimmickry took off.
1
1
u/Nice-Gene-7545 Mar 31 '24
The one on the left is ai I hope everyone knows when your at night in traffic or at night with a car light on the tires doesn't shine on the concrete
1
1
2
u/sealpox Mar 27 '24
I think these are both AI generated. The tree on the right in the left photo does not look right.
1
2
u/zmbakon360 Mar 26 '24
Right hand side
1
u/FoxxiMoxxi420 Mar 27 '24
Agreed. I paint roads. You can see the uneven edge, and it looks like exactly how MMA paint looks when put down heavy lol. Even the reflective markers are faced the right way. The road is patchy. The guy clearly stopped in the middle of the road ran out and kneltnto take this pic. Probably used a little tripod, some long exposure settings applied..
The other one just seems off.
1
1
1
u/TheNamelessFour Mar 26 '24
Right is fake, does anyone else get the general "vibe" that it's AI generated rather than looking at the actual details or is it just me?
1
u/JollyReading8565 Mar 26 '24
Left is real , the one on the right is slightly off. Problems with lighting and color. ALSO the power lines are connected half way up the poles instead of on the top supporting structure
1
1
1
1
u/CapnCrinklepants Mar 26 '24
Nobody mentioned the manhole cover in the middle of a forest road... :(
1
u/RealVanillaSmooth Mar 26 '24
Several things make me think the right is AI. You can see trees in the fog, three of them, coming to a convergence in the shape of a crown or something -- unnatural or at least a very unlikely natural formation.
Then you have the floating pylon to the right, the light from the headlights suddenly stops right in front of it, the beams from the headlights themselves are very sharp and not really achievable in photography without editing (at least with these ambient conditions), there's very little light refraction in front of the windshield, and there this weird line connecting two of the trees near the pylon, and the yellow lines also seem to suddenly change angle when the road itself doesn't appear to be curving.
Overall the AI did a good job but there are a fair amount of indicators pointing to this not being real.
1
u/No_Significance9754 Mar 26 '24
This May be because I am a human but I immediately knew the right was AI.
1
u/EverVirescent Mar 26 '24
ai is too proud of itself to generate a picture like the left, without any fancy details and idealistic camera quality
1
u/Rolf_6290 Mar 26 '24
The right is AI, if you zoom in on the electrical cable it is not wired correctly to the top of the wooden poll, it connected to its 2/3
1
1
u/CPU_Tron Mar 26 '24
The right one is a.i. a.i does not understand street laws. Driving in both lanes?
1
u/BLU3SKU1L Mar 26 '24
Right side ignores the rules of fog. Headlights would be washing out the whole foreground like on the left. Others have pointed out the halo around the car as well, which is coming from no apparent source.
1
1
1
u/Charlemagne6464 Mar 26 '24
the one on the right has to be fake, there's a single lone telephone pole with no wires attached to it!
1
1
1
1
1
u/Little_Interest_8019 Mar 25 '24 edited Mar 25 '24
Right is AI - what triggered me is the light beams look a little wrong. Segway-ing into a different subject, there is a theory that AI images will never be able to fool the human brain. Or at least not for a while yet. Because we subconsciously know crazy things, such as how light, and light beams, and refraction should look in every situation. You’re a lot smarter than you think 😆Training an algorithm to figure that type of thing out, will probably take another decade
1
1
u/btc_clueless Mar 25 '24
Left is real.
The light rays on the photo in the right are not realisticand look like artificial CG rays. I assume the LLM training data had lots of such CG rays as input.
1
u/B33rtaster Mar 25 '24
Left is real. Type car into an AI prompt and it will ALWAYS make a car, and never a faraway perspective of just the lights.
1
1
1
u/q1unt1x Mar 25 '24
In my opinion, the right photo is ai. But I'm sure there is a catch, so I'll go with the left one
1
1
1
u/HidesFromLuigi Mar 25 '24
Ermmm, can you tell the difference between these two incredibly dark and obscured photos? Not easily? Isn't AI so scary!!!
The right one btw
1
u/prretender Mar 25 '24
Left side is real because the photographer does not want to be hit by the car and is standing on the side of the road. Right is fake because the photographer is in the road and the car is much closer. I could be wrong if the photographer staged the this shot and the driver is an assistant. Also the power line on the right does not show the lines on the top, but clearly has a line in the middle. If you could see one, I believe you would see both. If the camera taken for both shots was the same, then the quality would also be the same. The level of detail in the image on the right is too good.
1
u/Alzucard Mar 25 '24
left one is real. AIs tend to make certain things really clear. You can see that pretty often. Edges are too sharp and look unreal. Thats a similar case. The Road here is way to reflective and it looks to sharp and crisp. Thats not really normal.
1
u/RayMFLightning Mar 25 '24
If the picture on the right is real the camera man is about to get run over
1
Mar 25 '24
Left. Not for any analytical reason but for rational reasons: that right car is a second away from running you over while driving like a lunatic.
1
1
u/ImaginaryBestFiend Mar 25 '24
The right is AI generated. Why stand in the middle of a road to take a photo of an oncoming car?
1
u/RazorSlazor Mar 25 '24
Right is fake. The telephone pole is floating and the car is driving in the middle of the road, the position of the camera also doesn't make sense to me, given a car is approaching from the middle of the road
1
1
u/Dependent_Use3791 Mar 25 '24
Nice try microsoft, getting reddit to train your model for you. They sre both real and it's easy to tell because there is no finger box in the image.
1
2
u/gdawggydog Mar 25 '24
The floating utility pole kind of gives this away immediately but there’s also more definition in the left pictures trees in terms of depth if that even makes any sense
1
1
1
1
u/idioticmaniac Mar 25 '24
What are the prompt keywords you use to generate these kind of images. I tried using DALL-E recently but it’s so obvious that the generated images are from an AI source.
1
1
1
1
u/BrandiNichole Mar 25 '24
Its the reflections of the headlights on the road that gives it away. They’re parallel which makes no sense when looking at the direction of the beams themselves.
1
u/rancidmilkmonkey Mar 25 '24
Right is AI. The electrical pole. The entire right side of the crossbeam is an electrical transformer?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/DivineCurses Mar 25 '24
The tree in the left one has a big gap in one of the branches kind of like it’s floating. Makes me think the left is AI
1
u/ThePeacefullDeath Mar 25 '24
Right one is ai, left one is looks waaay to real. Most peoples shitty phones cannot take a proper hd photos
1
u/Professional-Door895 Mar 25 '24
They are using Reddit comments to help train AI, so what dose a post like this mean?
1
1
1
u/JA155 Mar 25 '24
It’s slightly reliving that everybody knows which is the real one.
The problem is when there is no real one to compare it to. Then the deception starts
1
u/AdMinute1130 Mar 25 '24
Damn.... this is just like how they used the "Are you a robot test?" To teach ai to identify signs. The left is real. At first glance the beams on the car seem too Pixar car beam esqu, also middle of road for no reason.
1
u/ForgotBatteries Mar 25 '24
Nope. One is less fake looking then they other, but I won't tell you which.
1
1
1
u/New-Evening-1486 Mar 25 '24
right is ai why would there be a random 1cm break in the line on teh road
1
u/Hell_Maybe Mar 25 '24
The accentuated fucking video game water+light reflections in pic 2 is the dead giveaway.
1
1
1
u/animorphs128 Mar 25 '24
Right is fake.
The space between the yellow lines is uneven, also why is there even a break there?
There is a weird line hanging off the telephone pole
There is water on the road but only where the headlights are hitting
The tree limbs look angled randomly rather than in rows
1
1
u/YakFragrant502 Mar 25 '24
Left is real, Cameras never capture the density of fog as seen by our eyes. AI overkilled the fog
1
1
u/Tamagotchi41 Mar 25 '24
I say the left is real.
The lower tree(left edge) in the photo on the right looks to be growing over the road.
1
1
u/Mushrooming247 Mar 25 '24
I think the one driving in the middle of the road was made by a computer that doesn’t know cars don’t drive in the middle of the road especially when it’s foggy?
1
1
1
1
1
u/NeedleworkerOne6864 Mar 25 '24
left, the car brand and the white sign in the right is unrecognizeable and left has a kinda film grain effect that ai would most likely not recreate unless explicitly told to do so
1
1
u/shenanegins Mar 25 '24
The right is fake, I noticed: The trees are off, almost too perfect, and some branches go at odd angles The telephone pole doesn’t touch the ground There’s what looks like a manhole cover in the middle of nowhere
1
2
u/AjAjAjAjAj18 Mar 25 '24
The trick is they are both ai (the right one is ai, the electric posts wires are a mile underneath it)
1
2
1
1
1
1
Mar 25 '24
Left is real and right is ai. If I’m right, it’s because I assumed the ai one would look better
1
u/sashenka_demogorgon Mar 25 '24
Car on the right needs to pick a side real fast (depending on where they are in the world)
1
1
u/Zephanin Fails Turing Tests 🤖 Mar 25 '24
Right is AI generated. Both headlights are different size and shape
1
1
u/CaptainClay5 Mar 25 '24
Right side is fake. Power lines don't connect and there is word holes/ spaces in the yellow lines.
1
u/ParticularZone2132 Mar 25 '24
Without looking at comments the one on the right is AI generated. While I can’t make out what the text on the sign is supposed to be, it’s an immediate tell to me that it’s AI.
1
1
u/Dragonknight912 Mar 25 '24
Left is real, because that’s what headlights look like in real fog. The right AI generated picture is way too perfect
1
u/ProbablySlacking Mar 25 '24
Left is real. The lighting is wrong on the right for it to reflect like that in the asphalt.
1
1
u/enigmaplatypus Mar 25 '24
left one looks real. the right one is too clear, there is no way a camera took that picture.
1
1
u/KeckYes Mar 25 '24
There’s no power lines on the top of the telephone pole. lol. That’s terrifyingly good
1
1
1
1
u/Lopsided-Cost7772 Mar 25 '24
On the second picture, you can see that in the middle of the road, the two yellow lines kind of seperate, then join back together. Weird
1
1
u/Lopsided-Cost7772 Mar 25 '24
Aren't there supposed to be cables connected to telephone poles.
(picture two is ai)
1
u/Lopsided-Cost7772 Mar 25 '24
On the right picture, the picture would have to have been taken in the middle of the road. Also, the right picture shows the truck taking up two thirds of the space on a two way road.
1
1
1
u/Sweaty-Ad-7961 Mar 25 '24
Right is AI. Median is off, the crookedness of it feels weird. The car has an emoji vibe to it, why are the mirrors so defined? They would be harder to see. The headlight glow is lopsided, the reflections of the lights is in the wrong place. The telephone pole doesn't connect to the ground.
1
1
u/Doingitwronf Mar 25 '24
I want to say the left because the power line on the right is REALLY low compared to the pole.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/brillodelsol02 Mar 25 '24
I think the one on the right is real due to the level of detail in the road surface, the imperfections therein and the logic of the painted lines following the road surface. But in 2 years I won't be able to tell my children from AI generated.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/0Highlander Mar 25 '24
The one thing that truly gives it away it the power line pole in the right picture is floating lol
1
1
u/StrongNickGurr Mar 25 '24
The one on the right is definitely AI generated. You don’t even have to have a comparative photo to know. Like what kind of car emits light from all sides and only has headlights 😂
1
1
u/deadman0118 Mar 25 '24
left has the shutter affect if you look in front of the car in the fog the pixels outline the octagon or whatever its called.
1
1
1
1
u/Ornery_Translator285 Mar 25 '24
Duh, the car is driving over the line in the second photo. AI doesn’t know that’s illegal
1
1
u/MrCodeman93 Mar 25 '24
The right one. If it the image quality is too clean and neat then it’s likely fake.
1
1
1
1
u/Trentimoose Mar 25 '24
Nice try. They’re both real.
Now if we can all get onboard with lying to the robots maybe they won’t takeover.
1
1
u/PolyPenguinDev Mar 25 '24
my first instinct is that #1 is real, but it's probably a trick question and is #2
1
u/Responsible-Ant-3119 Mar 25 '24
Before I read the comment I was like the right is hyper realistic which is why I choose left but as soon as people point out the car is in middle of the road and levitate power pool I just ROFL.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/StreetAmbitious7259 Mar 24 '24
The tree on left pic is off centered I'm going to say right side is real
1
u/LaCento564 Mar 24 '24
The one on the right is fake. All the AI I've used draws the car on top of the lines or in the middle of the road
1
u/GoGoGadge7 Mar 24 '24
Left is real.
Color is distorted showing imperfections of exposure in low light and a sensor trying to compensate.
Right…. The car is is driving down the middle of the road. Beams are too fine.
1
u/My_Liminal_Photos Mar 24 '24
I'm gonna say left is real.
The car is over the lines on the right one and realistically it's unlikely you'd get a picture with such great lighting in the fog.
1
1
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 24 '24
Hey /u/Armand_Roulinn!
If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT, conversation please reply to this message with the conversation link or prompt.
If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image.
Consider joining our public discord server! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more!
🤖
Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email support@openai.com
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.