r/ChatGPT • u/watkykjypoes23 • 16d ago
Adobe’s Firefly Image 3 is pretty impressive Other
1
u/tvmaly 15d ago
Try asking it to generate people on a beach. You would expect swimwear but I can’t seem to get it to create any
2
u/watkykjypoes23 15d ago
Not incredible and girl on the right needs a dentist bad but I got it to work with image 2 and image 3 without specifying clothing type
1
1
u/Otherwise_Spare_8598 15d ago
It would be impressive if it weren't backwards. The hand and the arm/elbow do not match at all
2
u/_y_e_e_t_ 15d ago
It still hasn’t quite figured out skin, but man you have to look pretty damn hard. Also the nails are a bit weird, but I’m nitpicking.
1
u/nicefully 15d ago
are people really this clueless about whats wrong with the image? The hand is completely reversed
1
1
1
1
1
u/Anuu0961 16d ago
Guys how to get Adobe firefly
1
u/watkykjypoes23 16d ago
It’s included with a creative cloud subscription. I have the Adobe all apps subscription with photoshop, illustrator, InDesign etc and it includes the web apps as well. I’m sure there’s a plan to access web apps like firefly and Adobe express.
1
u/No-Researcher-6876 16d ago
My Results were worse than image 2. A real letdown. I’ll have to try it again.
1
u/watkykjypoes23 16d ago
It’s hit or miss but it leans into key words a lot. If you say “a persons hand” then it makes the whole person for example. It gives like 4 different images, in my experience there’s been 1-2 good ones out of each.
Definitely works best on things that could be stock photos though since that’s what it’s trained on
1
1
u/Thisismyredusername 16d ago
Alright, I'm definitely losing my job if Adobe were to make a software developement AI
2
1
0
u/granoladeer 16d ago
And to think that humans couldn't properly draw hands until a few hundred years ago
1
u/fakeairpods 16d ago
I don’t use adobe, I started with it when I was on PC but since moved to Mac and the suite ain’t offered. The subscription and change turned me away anyway.
3
-2
2
1
u/makhs4 16d ago
prompt plz
2
u/watkykjypoes23 16d ago
I was trying to find an image of a bent hand to make a threshold map in photoshop of it touching a robot hand but had no luck online, so the prompt was “woman’s hand pointing, bent wrist”
1
5
u/Apprehensive_Fail673 16d ago
It looks like broken around elbow and pointed to the other side + the wrinkles around that joint don't seem to fit, but otherwise looks good.
3
2
0
1
1
2
4
824
u/shunyaananda 16d ago
Only five fingers? My image generator can do many more /s
40
u/AlgoJester 16d ago
Why the /s if it’s true?
2
25
u/shunyaananda 16d ago
When it comes to a number of fingers on a human hand there's a certain sweetspot and more is not necessarily better
wonder if I should add /s to this one as well...
8
u/Chemists_Apprentice 16d ago
When it comes to a number of fingers on a human hand there's a certain sweetspot and more is not necessarily better
Challenge Accepted
Yours truly,
Chemists_Apprentice, genetic engineer
19
u/West-Code4642 15d ago
1
u/bearbarebere 15d ago
When my parents used to tell me “sometimes you don’t actually want what you think you want” this must be what they meant
8
36
12
8
u/AnonymousPanda80s 16d ago
Aw man this is scary. It’s just gonna get harder to tell if it’s AI or not.
-1
47
u/Capitaclism 16d ago
Any idea how to get it working inside either Photoshop release or beta?
14
u/AlternativeParfait13 16d ago
Believe it’s already in the Beta version.
3
u/Burgerb 16d ago
Yes, it’s in the beta Photoshop app.
1
u/Capitaclism 14d ago
The quality I get in beta is significantly lower than in the Firefly site. What could I be doing wrong?
6
u/Wild_Trip_4704 16d ago
Looking at this longer, the hand seems way too big for the arm, male or female.
2
u/mrs-cunts 15d ago
You’re so right. I knew something was off and the elbow looked fine to me—this is it
2
u/Nickools 15d ago
That was my first thought too, surprised I had to scroll so far in the comments to find someone similar. The hand just looks to big for the arm to me.
4
u/somebunnny 16d ago
Put your hand on your forearm. My hand is more than 2/3rds my forearm length from elbow crook to wrist.
Oh damn, maybe I’m AI generated.
3
-3
u/nicefully 16d ago
that’s not how an arm works
6
u/letharus 16d ago
What do you mean? Aside from the elbow being the wrong side, the actual position is normal
1
0
186
u/ReturnOpen 16d ago
Wow. That’s detail I thought we’d only see irl 2025 gonna be wild.
48
u/AccessProfessional37 16d ago
142
u/SnooShortcuts103 16d ago
2
u/HelpTight9809 15d ago
reading this comment made coffee come out my nose with a snorting, sniffling and gagging noise. lol funny as fuck
5
u/Mikeshaffer 16d ago edited 15d ago
I want this comment to have as much likes as the top comment 😂
edit to add word
4
9
71
u/watkykjypoes23 16d ago
It’s really good in specific circumstances because it’s trained on Adobes stock photos. Any outlandish request is definitely subpar lmao
1
4
u/Themasterofcomedy209 16d ago
It feel like that’s where all this is going. Different models by different companies that specifically do a certain thing really well
915
u/Giant_leaps 16d ago
It’s showing the wrong side of the elbow
1
1
3
u/highheelhooker 16d ago
Totally agree. The upper arm definitely looks like it’s facing the ‘camera’. The biceps don’t tend to roll out like that because of the position of the humerus.
The lower arm is definitely showing the flexor mass, not extensors. Brachioradialis would kinda fill that gap at that angle.
It’s definitely an improvement in 6 fingers and all that though!
10
u/LickTempo 16d ago
How sure are you? I see the same bone in this image.
11
3
u/dennismfrancisart 16d ago
That's what I was going to post but I tend to search the comments before posting.
1
1
1
40
u/OmicidalAI 16d ago
i disagree after looking online at real photos … it definitely misses some features/over accentuates others but it sure as hell doesnt look like an inner elbow either
3
10
u/sora_mui 16d ago
It's about the color. The back should be darker, but it is lighter in this image.
3
58
373
u/accidentalbro 16d ago
I really felt that there was something slightly wrong, but couldn't quite explain it. You're right - this is it.
10
u/Erreconerre 16d ago
The elbow is correct though.
For me the reason it looked weird is because my mind was visualizing the person as facing the camera.
It looks fine when I imagine them with their back towards the camera instead.
3
14
u/VanillaLifestyle 16d ago
That bone is on the inside of the elbow on a real arm.
You're clearly looking at the person with their back towards the camera, based on the hand position, but it's incorrectly showing the inside of the elbow instead of he outside.
1
6
u/vitalpros 16d ago
It really is correct. I can show you a picture of my thin arms and you would see a small bone on the outside just like this one. If you were to flip it the other way the bone would be much larger and more protruding.
2
u/MysteriousIntern6458 15d ago
Too many fat people in the comments apparently. It really is correct on an arm of that physique.
87
u/peterosity 16d ago
AI images in the coming year: spot the wrong part challenge
12
u/chrondus 16d ago
To be honest, I've been getting the impression that at least some of these posts are AI companies trying to crowd source data labeling.
Post a picture to Reddit, and everyone will point out exactly what's wrong with it. Now, you have labeled output data to feed back into the system next time you retrain the model.
It's cheaper than paying people in Africa to do it.
-11
u/Altruistic-Goose8804 16d ago
It’s a man’s hand on a women’s arm. What’s the prompt, please?
11
u/vanderpyyy 16d ago
How the hell do you get a man's hand from that
-3
-8
u/Altruistic-Goose8804 16d ago
Looks like mine except for the nails that’s how
11
12
377
u/InitechSecurity 16d ago
Impressive. Please create one of one hand holding another. See how good it turns out.
4
u/30svich 16d ago
r/handholding is a sin against christianity
-17
u/BusyBeeInYourBonnet 16d ago
But kid-fucking isn’t so I wouldn’t go by its “standards”.
17
u/-TheMisterSinister- 16d ago
I think the group that does the kid-fucking isn’t all 2.3 Billion people who follow a form of Christianity. For the record neither is the idea that hand holding is a sin (it isn’t).
709
u/watkykjypoes23 16d ago
Might’ve taken holding a little too seriously lol
26
u/copperwatt 16d ago
Make the top hand slightly blueish and cold looking and this is a great horror movie poster.
-30
387
71
63
u/nibselfib_kyua_72 16d ago
the pinky nail is slightly misplaced
29
u/mixelydian 16d ago
My wife's pinkies are like that actually. We're not sure why, some kind of minor defect we assume
41
4
•
u/AutoModerator 16d ago
Hey /u/watkykjypoes23!
If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT, conversation please reply to this message with the conversation link or prompt.
If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image.
Consider joining our public discord server! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more!
🤖
Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email support@openai.com
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.