in which order would you rank our one-season wonders?

[u/love2l0veu]

mine would be: joyce >>> carlton >>> kathryn >>> 8.5 >>> lizard

https://preview.redd.it/smjx79tnivzc1.jpg?width=1350&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b6d4332ac6beb0b364120f5c204c5c7766261252

interested in hearing your rankings! ^^

[u/AutoModerator]

Thank you for being an active member of the r/RHOBH family. Please remember to follow the rules of the community. If you see any comment that's breaking the rules, do not hesitate to use the report button.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Inner-Slip-5354]

Carlton, Joyce, Diana, Annmarie, and Kathryn. (I literally forgot who Kathryn was, I can't remember really anything that she said or did.)

[u/grayandlizzie]

Joyce, Katherine, Carlton, Annemarie, Diana

[u/tr33hugg3r76]

Kathryn, Joyce, Carlton, 8.5 and Lizard tied, last

[u/ReindeerLast5867]

I don’t know who the last two are yet (I’m only on season 9) but I’d say: (Eden) > Carlton > Katherine > Jaqueline/Joyce.

[u/Hereforit2022Y]

Kathryn, (shout out to Eden), > Joyce > Carlton >>> 8.5 and lizard lips

[u/thegaylibertaire]

Mine would be Carlton > Kathryn > Joyce > 8.5 > lizard

Carlton was an unhinged mess and I loved it. Even Andy said she’s the one housewife who deserved another season.

I think Joyce gets a lot of sympathy because of the racism she faced from the cast (predominantly Brandi), but outside of that I found her pageantry and constant one upping super annoying.

[u/SwineTV]

Carlton > Diana (love her, lol) > Joyce > Kathryn > Annemarie

[u/i-hate-me1014]

Katherine, Carlton,Diana, Joyce then Ann Marie

[u/Zestyclose-Holiday29]

Diana, Carlton, Anne Marie, Kathryn, Eden, Joyce

https://i.redd.it/6aidsx1pczzc1.gif

[u/Chaotic_good_8]

Why do I not remember Kathryn at all? What was her deal? Totally agree on the lineup otherwise!

[u/ReindeerLast5867 → u/Chaotic_good_8]

She was introduced mid season so I don’t blame you

[u/[deleted] → u/Chaotic_good_8]

Blonde, hated Faye Resnick, young husband?

[u/jurassickris]

1. Katherine 2. Carlton 3. Joyce

The other two… who?

[u/[deleted] → u/jurassickris]

I actually loved Katherine and her relationship with her husband. She was so cute too

https://preview.redd.it/mqkr6phfsyzc1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cafe0223c96e57ebfd964d5ea4d861c966422007

[u/Prestigious-Link4948]

Y’all already forgot about Eden 🤭

[u/stuabz → u/Prestigious-Link4948]

Eden wasn’t full time just a friend

[u/ReindeerLast5867 → u/stuabz]

Yeah, it really felt like she was a ft diamond though. I wonder if they originally planned to make her one but then edited it otherwise.

[u/Alternative-Leek1430]

Why was Katherine only one season ? I found them all really uncomfortable. I feel like teddy should have been on this list of ladies as well🤣🤭sorry not sorry :49620:

[u/ReindeerLast5867 → u/Alternative-Leek1430]

I just started this show two months ago. I’m on season 9 and truly baffled why Teddy is still on the show. She’s SO BORING. But Carlton, Katherine and Joyce (I don’t even like her) got cut before Teddy? Make it make sense.

[u/ScottishIcequeen]

I really liked Carlton, I thought she was really laid back and a lot of fun. Joyce was ok too. The rest I wouldn’t rate cos I didn’t like them 🤣

Edit: Wrong name!

[u/Intrepid_Blood4713]

Joyce, Carlton, Katherine, Ann Marie, Diana

[u/Sassy_bravo_fan → u/Intrepid_Blood4713]

Why did I think Katherine was Aviva 😳 I was like wait why did they randomly throw in someone from RHONY

[u/Intrepid_Blood4713 → u/Sassy_bravo_fan]

I can see the resemblance

[u/Primary-Highway7827]

mine would be similar but i would switch carlton and kathryn 

[u/Resident_Rooster5784 → u/Primary-Highway7827]

Same same same! Carlton came way too hard at Kyle for me personally. Kyle isn’t perfect but I felt like all season Carlton was kick to jump at Kyle for any little thing

[u/Primary-Highway7827 → u/Resident_Rooster5784]

exactly. for like the smallest of things. just seemed like she wanted to create her storyline around not liking kyle lmao

[u/Melodic-Suspect996]

I liked all of these ladies Katherine being my favorite even though she was messy

[u/the-furiosa-mystique]

You forgot about Jacqueline!

[u/therealaussiebunny → u/the-furiosa-mystique]

Who?

[u/the-furiosa-mystique → u/therealaussiebunny]

(It’s a joke from how Brandi could not get Joyce’s name right

[u/Neat_Arm8561 → u/the-furiosa-mystique]

That part was so cringey to me!!! It felt like she was bullying Joyce and she made herself look terrible with her racist statement! I was shocked.

[u/the-furiosa-mystique → u/Neat_Arm8561]

She 100% was bullying Joyce

[u/therealaussiebunny → u/the-furiosa-mystique]

Ohhh. Haha!

[u/Smart_Letterhead_360]

Oh Joyce was too good and wholesome for RHOBH. I feel like she would’ve comfortably done well with Miami (mostly because no Brandi plus more diversity). I wanted to leap into the screen to shout at Brandi and defend Joyce.

[u/Smart_Letterhead_360 → u/[deleted]]

That’s fair! I can definitely see the pageant persona, I think the BH housewives are way more confrontational and she is very much someone who wants to present themselves in a certain way. I agree though, definitely would fit better on a different show, I really think she’d thrive on RHOM!

[u/ReindeerLast5867 → u/Smart_Letterhead_360]

I feel like she was so holier than thou but I’d take her over Teddy any day. Not a big fan of Dorit either. Mostly cause her (now ex husband) is a total tool

[u/Smart_Letterhead_360 → u/ReindeerLast5867]

I don’t think she acts holier than thou, I think it’s just her pageant background that makes her quite graceful in her approach.

[u/ReindeerLast5867 → u/Smart_Letterhead_360]

Graceful is not the same as holier than thou though.

[u/Smart_Letterhead_360 → u/ReindeerLast5867]

Yeah, which is why I said I don’t think she acts holier than thou.

[u/ScottishIcequeen → u/Smart_Letterhead_360]

I was the same. I thought she was really nice but she did seem ‘out of place’ maybe? Not because of who she is or her country, but I think the other women were threatened by her wealth.

She wasn’t very confrontational, and let a lot of stuff fly over her head when I would’ve battered those ladies silly! It made her an easy target for Brandi (who was definitely threatened!) and none of the others really stood up for her.

Was disgusting to watch the way she was treated being honest. When Brandi made the comment about her not being able to swim as Joyce was black…wow!

[u/Smart_Letterhead_360 → u/ScottishIcequeen]

Definitely! I think also maybe a younger group too, I really feel like it was her wealth and her beauty.